The question behind it
When an application asks for hardship, how much of your life belongs on the page?
The tension between a private experience and a public-facing narrative drives the reporting. Compare what the prompt actually requests with what applicants think they must disclose. Do not encourage trauma performance or frame painful disclosure as the winning strategy.
What we want to examine
Read published prompts and rubrics, ask reviewers what they assess and interview applicants about boundaries without requiring them to recount trauma. Check how sensitive submissions are handled and retained.
Compare exact published prompts and evaluation criteria, then interview applicants and scholarship administrators. Distinguish optional personal context from an explicit disclosure requirement. Let participants discuss the process without recounting trauma. Ask about privacy, retention and alternatives, without claiming that painful disclosure increases selection odds.
Personal experience can tell us which question to ask. It cannot stand in for broader evidence. The finished story will distinguish what participants describe from what records establish.