Lesson 7: Did one complaint get the novel banned? Printable pages
Print the student pages or the educator pages for this case. Start with your grade band. The educator pages show every student page with sample answers and notes beside it.
Grades 6–8
Task: Draw the steps of a book review and write a message correcting the group chat.
Students make: Flowchart plus 3–4 sentence message.
One class period: 45 minutes. Full chapter: 69 minutes.
Educator pages
Open on screen Print this case Download PDF, 570 KBStudent pages
Open on screen Print this case Download fillable PDF, 455 KBGrades 9–10
Task: Write input to the review committee using the published selection criteria.
Students make: Written input, 150–200 words.
One class period: 50 minutes. Full chapter: 91 minutes.
Educator pages
Open on screen Print this case Download PDF, 590 KBStudent pages
Open on screen Print this case Download fillable PDF, 464 KBGrades 11–12
Task: Write a briefing on the law and policy of school library challenges for student council.
Students make: Briefing, 450–550 words.
One class period: 60 minutes. Full chapter: 91 minutes.
Educator pages
Open on screen Print this case Download PDF, 477 KBStudent pages
Open on screen Print this case Download fillable PDF, 473 KBCollege and community
Task: Write an explainer for a public library newsletter or a campus newspaper on how a school library review works. Use the district’s reconsideration notice as the example. Separate the district’s adopted policy, the ALA’s guidance and what courts have and have not settled.
Students make: Explainer, 450–600 words, with a labeled source list.
One class period: 90 minutes. Full chapter: 101 minutes.
Educator pages
Open on screen Print this case Download PDF, 614 KBStudent pages
Open on screen Print this case Download fillable PDF, 482 KBCourse editions
These editions include this case. “Print this case” opens the educator edition on screen and your browser’s print dialog.
- Honors (set by your school) Open on screen Print this case
- Pre-AP English 1 and Pre-AP English 2 Open on screen Print this case
- Pre-IB (a school pathway, not an IB program) Open on screen Print this case
- IB Middle Years Programme (MYP) Open on screen Print this case
- AP English Language and Composition Open on screen Print this case
- AP United States Government and Politics Open on screen Print this case
- AP Seminar Open on screen Print this case
- IB Diploma Programme: Language A: language and literature Open on screen Print this case
- IB Diploma Programme: Global politics Open on screen Print this case
Family page
One page to send home: a short summary of the case and three questions to talk about. Nobody needs to share personal stories to use it.
Family page Lesson 7: Did one complaint get the novel banned?
In this case, a group chat claims one parent’s complaint got a novel banned from a school library. Your student compared that claim with the library’s notice and learned how a book review works.
Questions to talk about
- What is the difference between a book being reviewed and a book being removed?
- Where could someone find out how a library decides which books to keep?
- How can people disagree about a book without attacking each other?
Read the case together: noperowhy.pages.dev/cases/matilda